I'm only 23, and I've only been a Star Wars fan since around '97 or so, but even when I saw Ep. 1 I was disappointed.
The ending of Episode 3 was epic, though. For the first time, there was a sense of internal cosmetic consistency between the a prequel and the originals. (The computers were "old-fashioned" looking, with all the bells and whistles! Why Mr. Lucas. . . why couldn't that have been the look for the entirety of the prequel trilogy???)