I'm glad you asked, AF. I know that I'm apparently one of the few people who actually liked Prometheus, which surprised me, because I thought a lot more people did.
I do have to agree with you on editing. It was a little uneven at times, like you said. But it wasn't too big a deal for me. I went in expecting something fun and "Alienish", and that's what I got. Maybe I was anticipating a lot less than you guys were, or something else along those lines. I barely watch TV anymore, so I didn't see too many trailers, which is another thing that seems to be coming up in reviews: that the trailers gave too much away.
Plus, the last few movies I have seen in theatres have been real stinkers, so it really elevated this movie for me, in terms of enjoyment.
Maybe after my excitement over a brand-new alien film is over, I may start to see more of it for what it is. As of now, however, I genuinely find it to be a good movie.