asterisk8 said:

Adywan is as close as you can get to a professional while still being a faneditor. I like to think he betters George Lucas in being open to criticism and not just blind praise. Surrounding himself with "yes men" is exactly what made Georgie's prequels so awful (imo).

Exactly my thoughts. I would rather have us nitpick it to pieces and Ady decide he likes it as is than have everyone universally praise everything he does. That way he at least is aware of any perceived issues. I think it should be assumed that we find anything he puts out there to be spectacular and far superior to the Special Editions.