Batman: Year One
Even though it was pretty close to the comic, which I love, it felt really over the top a lot of the time. I think some of the things worked better in still images. However, I still found it really enjoyable.
Bryan Cranston may well be the perfect James Gordon. I love Gary Oldman, but I think Cranston nailed the character (of course, comparing voice work to a full live action role isn't always fair, Cranston also has the look for the role, and no doubt the ability).