I thought it was a pretty average Star Trek film, as entertaining and silly as Nemesis, (the plot is practically the same which is ironic as it is itself a remake of TWOK) which had pretty much no connection to anything remotely Star Trek that had gone before.
It's a timeline where only Enterprise remains unaltered.
Why bother calling it Star Trek at all...?
It's New Coke only this time the right critics were paid for it's selling well.