Bingowings said:
Magnificent Ambersons has been highly regarded for quite some time
Yes. Needs more regards. The most compromised film of all time. (Next to Greed.)
and if anything I think The Third Man (lovely as it is) is a tad overrated.
No. Never. (but I can understand if you think so.)
Take out Welles' very small role and you are left with a thriller that while stylishly filmed is largely unremarkable next to other films of he period.
No. Dear god no. In fact, I once argued with a professor for upwards of three hours that this was truly the first post-modern, post-war film. It is the world's alternative to Kane. One of the great works of art. It is one of the only films that can truly be considered alive and breathing. It knows the game, it knows how the world plays the game, and it is so terribly tired of the whole act of living in our so-called civilized world.
Falcon, that is a nice Welles overload for one day. Adding in TOE might have been the clincher. I remember the first time I saw it was in a film noir festival many years ago. I went in round midday and saw Out of the Past for the first time. Mesmerized. Blown away. Destroyed. Then I immediately went next door and walked into Touch of Evil.
Overloaded!
LMS:
The Getaway (1972)- Peckinpah-lite. I enjoy watching Steve McQueen, but this is just uninspired and drags along at times. There are some nice little touches, well choreographed action sequences, a great subplot-but completely uninspired and overly a dull movie.
2.5 balls out of 4 slaps.
Pat Garrett and Billy the Kid (1988 Turner Preview Version AKA Sam's rough cut): IMO The second greatest American western after The Wild Bunch. Dark, flawed, bitter, nasty, sour and achingly human version of the classic tale, where Pat Garrett is forced to hunt down his best friend and hates himself for it. Devastating. James Coburn deserved his Oscar for this film. The film feels real, and it is disturbingly painful. Gut-wrenchingly elegiac. Soundtrack by Bob Dylan (who also acts in the film). Theatrical version was butchered by a vengeful studio. The DVD features an inane edit by a fan/scholar. Avoid this and watch the second disc. Many claim it's only a rough edit, but after careful study, I don't think Peckinpah would have changed anything. Another masterpiece.
4 balls out of 4.