darth_ender said:
Wow, chill Ron. I admit the vote was flawed, but that doesn't make it binding either. I've tried to follow the general will of the people in the script, but at the same time, we can't make everything work.
For Han to deliberately hit the rocket pack, it may take little more than some line changing. It need not be anything drastic.
And ultimately, none of this has ever been binding. I've been the script writer who tries to follow the will of the people. And the editors have to actually implement the ideas, with us trusting their discretion. Many things may not work out as well as we'd hoped, and things will likely change before the movie is completed. This is all just a guide for a first attempt at this, and hopefully many other opportunities to do this will come.
I am chilled ok let me put it another way... For instance say an idea got voted in that luke decided to commit suicide and impale himself on his own lightsabre and won.... Then everyone walks away and scratches there head about how they would actually go about implementing it. Or simply give up and lets try somthing else.
I am talking about proving some of these "ideas" before they are up for vote as ultimatley it's perhaps easy to have the idea and impossible to implement or atleast it has not been proved yet or thought about properly and you are leaving yourself open to pitfalls with your edit.
I am trying to be helpfull and not slag off the vote only to try and make you be perhaps a bit more strict with the ideas themselves from now on rather than just accept things on face value without them being "proved" or alot more specific atleast
hope you understand me a bit better now :)
I'm not saying this stuff cannot be done but atleast all my ideas were proved either well or not so well... I just know that scene with Han and Boba is a nightmare to do anything with because I already been there and got rid of it to solve my problems in this scenario you opened the can I already threw away.
I hit many problems while doing my cut that I found ways to overcome stuff or workaround that you may not realise I already been there as I wanted to move han over to the right or remove him and could not do that so how you plan ti show him deliberatly hit his pack is beyond me thats all I'm saying