If this was posted on theforce.net in 2003, I would have at least thought it was original, however misguided. Sadly, I've heard all these fallacies and strawman arguments ad nauseum. It's all a bunch of horseshit. Plus, as someone pointed out, an interesting idea terribly executed is still just something terribly executed. It would be better to watch a bad idea masterfully executed. The only thing the former has going for it is that it might make you think, but all you can think about is how bad it was all done.

Whatever. I guess with the re-release there is one of these amid all the bad reviews. Fun for the fans of the prequels, but I doubt it will sway anyone. People might say "hmm, interesting, I should take a second look," and then after 15 minutes of Episode I will laugh at themselves, turn the movie off and do something more productive with their life.