Pretty lukewarm, so far. The first was glad that the 3D wasn't over-the-top, but felt it had some technical issues, and still found the movie highly problematic. The second one isn't crazy about the movie, but enjoys having a Star Wars film on the big screen, but ultimately feels the 3D conversion itself is poor. I'm more curious to see how critics re-evaluated the film a decade later, but these samples seem to be basically saying the same thing as the negative-moderates of 1999. I guess we'll see how this develops.