Nebula said:
It's funny that he gives out earlier snapshots and later on saying that he's corercted them without giving any proof visually. (Awaiting the final release is the best excuse I've ever heard. If you want to get feedback about your work and maybe it will be good, then show us your final shots. I think it's common sense).
Having read through some of your ramblings Nebula, it seems you take big issue with adywan's edit. Unfortunately, I can't pin down exactly what your exact beef with it is, as your comments are unspecific, and a little confusing overall.
Nevertheless, you're certainly entitled to your opinion regardless, however negative. Having said that, you seem to be quite a rude bugger if some of your initial posts are anything to go by.
Fair enough, but I'd just like to clarify something for you to do with your above comments - as one of those that have seen a very incomplete 'workprint' of ESB:R, I can assure you that adywan definately *has* continually improved on certain shots that he's only so far shown in an early, unfinished version on this thread. And those have been dramatically improved on now, as far as I'm concerned, compared to the early versions. You'll just have to accept my word on that, but he certainly doesn't owe it to any of us to keep showing every little additional amendment that he makes along the way. And althought he's previewed heaps of things already, he's also previously mentioned how he'd like to keep quite a few touches undisclosed as a 'surprise' for those interested, when the edit is finished.
And adywan has certainly shown that he's open to constuctive 'feedback' from others, even though these edits are mainly for his own satisfaction at the end of the day.
However, I'm kinda unclear why you'd even be concerned about wanting to give your opinion on totally finished screenshots anyway, seeing as you seem to be so against this thing in the first place...
@ adywan - sorry to hear of the recent spate of 'hate-mail' you've mentioned on Facebook that you've received recently. How ridiculous that some feel bothered by your own 'unofficial' enhancements to these movies, for your own enjoyment. Don't let any of that nonsense distract you from the fact that you're putting some wonderful imagination and artistry into your projects. If they aren't interested in your alternative take on these, then they've still got their own preferred versions readily available to them, so what's their issue?
And I'm hoping you'll get a chance to get round to some of those responses/answers on here you'd intended recently, but were unable to manage because of your connection problems.