darth_ender said:

But there's a great deal of symbolism to the whole object, not just the crystal.

Anyway, I got a PM from MrInsaneA.

MrInsaneA said:

And my opinion of your edit? Well I didn't like how you restructured the land battle of Endor, except towards the end when Han and the Rebels break into the bunker. It's kind of hard to judge how it flows because a lot of scenes you want to have are soundless, or just still pictures with descriptions. But it's full of some good concepts. With a lot of tweaking, it could be great.

I hope to get more feedback on the video because I think a good rough edit will give us more direction on how the battle will ultimately play out. I still believe there are things that could be added, particularly to the space battle. Anyone else have any thoughts they feel like sharing. I know it's nowhere near perfect, but if anyone can think of how to sharpen the concepts, that would be appreciated.

How do edits normally start, do people usually do these rough cuts and compare notes thrash it out, or what or is this somewhat of a new thing?

I am quite new here... ahem