Mithrandir said:
Wandering... Is it too nuts if ObiWan communicated with Vader at some point?
Vader's return could have deeper reasons than Luke. I think that the feel of being "conned" by the Emperor could be one of them.
Though this could add some "market" sense to Vader (and therefore, the story) , in terms of :
EPIII: "I wanna be inmortal, the Emperor knows how, so Ill be a Sith"
EVI:" Remember that I wanted to be inmortal? Well, ObiWan figured out how, so Ill be a Jedi again. "
However, if we manage to keep that feeling off, I think that Anakin's past striking on Vader could emerge as an intreresting plot-line. We could use meditation chamber footage or standing on brdige footage to make it, I don't know.
Regarding what's been said about Vader being a strong character, my pov is that "strong" in terms of violence cames out when one is weak minded and conflicted. So I think that until the very end, Vader must come more closed to himself, less speaking and more violent.
That's the natural reaction of a beast when he's in fear or pain; they can be quiet for hours not making a sound, but when you touch them, they attack you.
Greetings!
Yes it is a good Idea, Obi-Wan new though in a new hope Vader was after all the Chosen one.... The only line you possibly would need is repeating "you can't win Darth..." For Vader to Hear Obi-wan say these words might make him realise the full meaning only now.And realise Obi-Wan was etherial
The teacher serves his final lesson
no need for the "Strike me down now..." no need to even see Obi-wan
When?... Possibly before the Emporers Arrival at Death star II
would that help your idea?
or in a flash back style start with the aforementioned Line and then
Emporer "He could be a great asset to us"
Luke "I'll never Join You!"
"you were the Chosen One!"
like voices in Vaders Head I'm probably overdoing it there i think....but the 1st idea might work well...