Mithrandir said:

Angel said:

Do you see the difference as a more accurate film feel?

Not the best example of saving the washed out edge arround Luke's head still you might get a taste.

The inbetween edges between the glow and the obsured object must contain color and edge effects.

It has to have the edge like it was printed and burned the pixels not just substracting the object. :)

-Angel

The man's got a point, and a strong one.Ady wants ESB:R to look like what it is: a film of the 80's, only that with improved technical quality. But yet a film, not a digital transfer.

What Angel is claiming is directly related to how a film phisically behave as a consequence of the rotoscoping and exposure process the analogical FX for a lightsabre needs.

So, in terms of "real 80`s look" he's being accurate. There's never (before the digital era) been a "perfect" mask, since it always ends up burning a little bit of the original print benneath it.

Greetings!

I wish I could see what you guys see.....Clearly I don't have an eye for this sort of thing. To me it's the same identical pic. And that's with pressing my eyeballs up to an IPS screen.