logo Sign In

Post #554147

Author
OMEN-_-
Parent topic
Harmy's STAR WARS Despecialized Edition HD - V2.7 - MKV (Released)
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/554147/action/topic#554147
Date created
7-Dec-2011, 12:27 PM

Okay Harmy, apologies for the delay, the clip's pretty long so I've been waiting to free up enough time to be able to go through it in its entirety. To speed things up in relation to pinpointing certain shots, i'm going to just state the frame number of the shot rather than the timecode in the clip, I hope you're fine with that. I not, let me know and i'll use the time codes instead. I'll put to one side my own project's colour grading in order to try and give as objective feedback as possible. All the shots I don't mention I think are fine as they are and this is of course all just IMHO. Here goes...

 

616: blue lettering is too dark

1151: 'Star Wars' letters and prologue scroll too dark

3934-3935: lighting inconsistent between the two shots

4223-4224: lighting inconsistent between the two shots

4287-4288: lighting inconsistent between the two shots

4999-5000: lighting inconsistent between the two shots

6283: too much red in shot relative to previous shot of c3po

6325: too much red/orange relative to previous corridor shots

6353: too much red/orange relative to previous corridor shots

6488: too much red/orange relative to previous corridor shots

6692: shot too dark relative to previous shots

6853: shot too dark relative to previous shots

7094: shot too bright for dark surroundings

8044: little bit too much red/orange relative to previous corridor shots

9124: shot perhaps a little too bright for dark surroundings

9200: shot perhaps a little too bright for dark surroundings

9261: shot a little too bright for dark surroundings

9288: shot too dark and inconsistent with previous shots of leia

10286: shot perhaps a little too dark relative to previous shots

10547: shot perhaps a little too dark

11029: shot a little too orange

11109: shot too orange, making leia's flesh tone overly orange

11165: shot a little too orange

11270: shot too orange, making leia's flesh tone overly orange

11377: shot a little too orange

11457: shot inconsistent with previous shot of leia, far too orange

11591: shot a little too orange

11618: shot inconsistent with previous shots of leia, far too orange

11645: much better, this is how whole scene should be colour graded IMHO, with a bit less orange to fit with the next shot

14830: sky too red

16115: sky a little too red relative to previous shot

16383: looks a little to red/orange compared to proceeding shots

22165: clouds/sky too red relative to previous shot with storm troopers

22570-22571: too bright at the end of shot, inconsistent with next shot

23185-23186: brightness/saturation inconsistent between shots

24218-24219: brightness/saturation inconsistent between shots

24305-24306: brightness/saturation inconsistent between shots

 

Going to take a break for a little bit but i'll be back to finish off. Hope this helps. :)