logo Sign In

Post #554089

Author
ww12345
Parent topic
Harmy's STAR WARS Despecialized Edition HD - V2.7 - MKV (Released)
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/554089/action/topic#554089
Date created
7-Dec-2011, 1:23 AM

OK, finally downloaded the workprint, and here are my rough notes about what I saw. I mainly looked at color consistencies/inconsistencies. I listed the approximate timecodes for the events.

 

4 min. - Stormtrooper beige color


6:50 min - stars in the escape pod shaft flickering? Is that correct?


"No one to stop us this time" - Vader's friend slightly brownish


12:50 min - bluish Sand Crawler lights


14:45 - too bright, washed out sand color


16:35 - also too bright?


20:03 - color levels/Luke's hair and skin tone


20:45 - squarish hologram "shadow" behind image


23:13 - bluish table - should be white? Luke's clothes are also a bit blue


24:50 - odd color switch between shots - goes from orangey in the Binary Sunset scene to greenish in the next shot


29:30 - Odd color levels - Obi-wan very pale/brown, compared to later in the shot or at his home


35:12 - Color of admiral different from later in the clip


Also, Princess Leia differently colored in detention cell; may be because of the whiter lighting as opposed to the reddish lighting on Tantive IV.

 

The good things I noticed:
Awesome  clarity of the Star Destroyer in the beginning shot/tractor beam shot. Did you use the BD as a source? Also, no "ghost Luke"!