Hot Rod I like how you mentioned your friends dogging you. That is a true fan to stay with it. I don't hate the new movies, its just hard to swallow next to the OT. TPM was truly disappointing, but had some glimpse of hope (hmmm...a new hope) when I found this edit, it may give me mostly what I was looking for...something that doesn't look and move like Shrek 2. ATOC is a good movie, I just expect more...as someone said...with that much money, resources (nearly billions), time (over 16 years), and fan base and intelligent writers that have been doing all these books&games...I expected more. I really expected more, like the sequels of the Matrix. They were good, but somewhat disappointing. But the LOTR trilogy was awesome the whole way through. I am not begging for re-edits of that. Peter Jackson did a Phenomenal job with the Extended editions...hopefully "the hobbit" comes out well too when he does that.