Looks like I'm getting some details wrong, but the online paper won't let me read the full articles, so I have to use this guy's relation of the story. Not quite how I remember it, but I'll let you read it. The second guy shot was Campas, the friend, if I remember correctly. He did not die. I don't think this was included in this link:

http://forums.randi.org/showthread.php?t=189441

As for your question, I guess I'd really have to sit on the jury and hear all the evidence, but even from what we glean in the deliberation, it seems pretty convincing to me. I won't say yes absolutely simply because of my lack of information, but I believe if I'd been present I would have done so.