I actually like the Sith from the movies better than the EU. To me they are overly powerful and the Jedi awfully stupid during the Sith War stuff. I like the Rule of Two (and I'm not fond of all the Sith acolyte stuff in the Clone Wars). I like their subversive nature rather than another large group. I like that their evil is subtle and infiltrating instead of a big group that everyone knows is evil. Just my two cents.

Somewhat reconsidering what I said about the Chosen One...it could be made to better appeal to me in the OT if done right, and maybe I'd be happier with it overall. I confess, the main thing I don't like about it is its lack of reference in the OT, but if it were included more, it might be better in my mind as another way of looking at Star Wars. I really do like having several interpretations of Star Wars, not simply an "only way to watch it."