Jar jar binks is the stupidest thing to be in star wars. He never shuts up! And Lucas loves him!!! All he does is yell and annoy people to death. Honestly, Jar Jar and Episode II are the main reasons the prequels sucked!!!!! Who agrees??
Ultimatejedi04
Yeah, I guess.
I think that if Jar Jar never existed in the prequels and they fixed attack of the clones they would of all been better
Jar Jar and the other stupid things in the prequels (midichlorians, creepy puppet yoda, bad love scenes) save them from just being boring. That's why I prefer them over "good" fan edits. I'd rather see something that sucks than something that is boring.
"Close the blast doors!"
Puggo’s website | Rescuing Star Wars
Sometimes I wonder if newbie posts like this are exasperated sighs of relief for people who have found like minded Star Wars fans... or if they are simply way over the top simply to try and win brownie points with the regulars.
Either way, Yeah, Jar Jar is a pain... but I back Puggo here. I just finished an hour long cut of Episode 1, and cut quite a bit of everything... but Jar Jar is fine in a comic relief capacity, so long as he is used appropriately and when necessary for pacing. It gets too bland without him.
Preferred Saga:
1/2: Hal9000
3: L8wrtr
4/5: Adywan
6-9: Hal9000
Jar Jar is a single drop in a bucket of bad ideas that saturate the prequels. Alone he is an irritant, an annoyance, nothing more; he can be ignored. But when more and more other irritants and annoyances join him ...
George Lucas is the ONLY thing responsible for the prequels awfulness.
Since they're like poetry, what with the rhyming and all, I find that I only need to watch three out of the six films.
nightstalkerpoet said:
Sometimes I wonder if newbie posts like this are exasperated sighs of relief for people who have found like minded Star Wars fans... or if they are simply way over the top simply to try and win brownie points with the regulars.
I've wondered if they're not just sock accounts made by those that would like to point to threads like these to try and discredit the site.
I think RedLetterMedia, as usual, put it quite well. Jar Jar is just a "cartoon rabbit who steps in the poopy" and the prequels would have been just as bad without him. He's barely in AoTC or RoTS and those films still suck.
Ya lucas did go mad with power and they,should of had a diffrent director for t hIhe prequels
And I love this site and imma hardcore fan!!Always have!!! I like just having a star,wars conversation with alot of people.
Plus om still tryong to get the hang of things on OT
Advice: Don't post twice or thrice in a row. Spelling and grammare are important.
timdiggerm said:
Spelling and grammare are important.
HA!
would have all been better.Ultimatejedi04 said:
I think that if Jar Jar never existed in the prequels and they fixed attack of the clones they would of all been better
should have had a different director.Ultimatejedi04 said:
should of had a diffrent director
ray_afraid said:
timdiggerm said:
Spelling and grammare are important.
HA!
...totally did that on purpose, for the irony.
Of course.
Ultimatejedi04 said:
I like just having a star,wars conversation with alot of people.
;-)
Ultimatejedi04 said:
I like just having a star,wars conversation with alot of people.
Greatest use of a comma EVER.
You're just jealous because you don't have a star.
Are we being too hard on the new guy?
no we are, not
You know of the rebellion against the Empire?
Weesa no be hard on new guy...
God, I wish this was in Off Topic.
But I think there is merit in what Puggo says.
The blue elephant in the room.
Honestly, this is one of those threads where the topic is either in Ric Olie territory or has been previously debated to death (both here and elsewhere).
Seems like as good a reason to move it off-topic as any, but it won't happen.
TV's Frink said:
Honestly, this is one of those threads where the topic is either in Ric Olie territory...
Seems like as good a reason to move it off-topic as any, but it won't happen.
Off-topic is one option.
Grammare is always important, especially in first impression situations like this one.
Plus, we don't need another kenkraly2007.