TheBoost said:

Mrebo said:

http://www.listology.com/litgeek/story/vebber-and-goulds-fifty-reasons-why-jedi-sucks-rebuttal

I don't have the desire to do a thorough rebuttal to the "50 Reasons Jedi Sucks" link a couple pages back but fortunately someone else did. It's a multipart reply but that's the first page for anyone interested.

While that list is sure rebuttal worthy, this dude's work is a little weak. Lots of "George's vision" stuff, including faulting the first list for calling "Star Wars" "Star Wars" and not ANH.

Yeah, yeah, I agree...but I don't want to do my own rebuttal!

Some of the 50 Reasons are just so completely stupid, it's hard to rebut them beyond stating the obvious (eg #12 3PO is annoying and doesn't serve an integral purpose...what else is new?). Eh, maybe I'll be less lazy and respond to the first 10 or something.