twooffour, lol, you really get your teeth into something. I'm afraid the whole discussion will get overwhelmed/confused/devolved. The argument is about claiming RoTJ is the worst of 6 movies without explaining how it is the worst of 6 movies. This point doesn't need to be driven into the ground because that just gets unpleasant.

So, as I conceded from my very first post, sonnyboo, your criticisms have some merit and I agree with some of them. But even if I agreed with all of them completely, I don't see how you conclude RoTJ is worse than the PT. And certainly you're entitled to believe that, but you haven't explained it.

RoTJ is my favorite and I like Ewoks. You're certainly not going to convince me otherwise and you've rightfully stated that isn't your motivation. But I would like to understand your thoughts that you wish to express.