logo Sign In

Post #541867

Author
Bring_My_Shuttle
Parent topic
My Top 10 Reasons ROTJ sucks
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/541867/action/topic#541867
Date created
29-Sep-2011, 3:37 PM

Pretty good writeup and I agree with a lot, even if I don't think some are that detrimental.


6. KILL LANDO - have to disagree big time.  Lando's cool, while Han was cardboard in ROTJ by comparison...

3. HARRISON FORD - I know people would be outraged etc., if they killed off Han but I agree he phoned it in.

The biggest fail in ROTJ imo is Leia being Luke's sister.  This is the beginning of the end, the seed from where the PT snowballed into ever increasing "connections" that stretch logic and become ludicrous.  It's awkwardly handled by all the characters dealing with it.  The whole "point of view" dialogue sucked to begin with, and then they had to add this to it.  ugh.

Han dies, Leia is distraught but then perhaps hooks up with Luke.  Lando becomes the new "Han", he already knew the Falcon and Chewie.

Just now need to find the other "last hope" mentioned in ESB, or maybe just let that go.