logo Sign In

Post #541825

Author
WhatsMyName
Parent topic
My Top 10 Reasons ROTJ sucks
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/541825/action/topic#541825
Date created
29-Sep-2011, 2:00 PM

cthulhu1138 said:

#5

DEATH STAR II. They could have filled that slot with anything they wanted, another super weapon, a massive star destroyer facility, anything.

Hell, it could have been a massive Imperial shipyard orbiting Endor. The Empire could be mining raw materials from the moon. This would piss the Ewoks off and give more of a reason for them to join with the Rebels.

#1

That "certain point of view" schtick was unnecessary. Are we really supposed to believe that Obi-Wan honestly thinks that Anakin Skywalker died when Darth Vader was born? Because if that's not what he believes then why give that speech in the first place. He could have just flat-out told Luke that he wasn't ready to hear the truth yet. What would Luke have done, rushed to face his father as a completely untrained farmboy? Obi-Wan could have even admitted that maybe he was wrong for holding the information from him. It would have given more honesty to his character to admit error to Luke and would lead in nicely to admitting error in training Anakin.

 Could have been the Kuat Shipyards that are mentioned so much in the EU. Those who've played the Empire at war expansion, they could of used the SSD Eclipse. The one that has a super laser, not powerful enough to destroy an entire planet, but whole dreadnuaght size or however big the biggest ship is.

I agree they really need to fix that stupid point of view thing. Yoda kind of played it right.

Luke: "Unfortunate that i know the truth?"

Yoda: "You weren't ready for the heavy burden."

I know i skipped a few lines but i was trying to get to the main point.