TV's Frink said:

TheBoost said:

I'm firewalled and cant read the blog in the OP. Anybody feel like cutting/pasting it?

Thanks Frink. You're OK, I don't care what everyone says about you. :)

Some of this is opinion, and if I disagree with it I don't necessarily think it's silly. Much is very good points. But since this is a nit picky message board, let me pick some nits.

VADER: Okay, even in the context of all 6 movies, When, where, and how did Luke sense some good in Vader? What actions were taken that demonstrate this innate sense of good?

That's the whole point. ONLY Luke senses it. Not Yoda, not Ben, not me or you. Only Luke has what it takes to redeem Vader. And he's right.

Han Solo in this movie is unmotivated, poorly acted, and completely inconsistent with anything ever this guy has done in the 2 previous movies.

I disagree with inconsistent. I say he's changed. They came back for him. I don't think Han Solo ever said "I owe you one" to anyone in his life before ROTJ. Han is now a team player, someone willing to volunteer to help the Rebellion and I think for the first time, he's someone deeply in love.