sonnyboo said:

Just finished the blu ray set. I wrote a blog about why ROTJ is the worst of the 6 movies.

Agree on point #10. That scene has always bothered me. Between the stilted acting, lack of logic and continuity (did Leia know ["somehow I've always known..."] that she was Luke's sister when they locked lips in ESB?), and the fact that she doesn't seem bothered at all that Vader is also her father. Definite low point for me.

Never thought much about point #1, but Kasden's draft would make for a better scene imo.

As for the rest. While I don't necessarily disagree with you, the kid in me, with rose-colored glasses firmly in place, just doesn't care. :)