As the original poster of the comment that started the whole firestorm, he does have a point. I foolishly compared this project with his, when one is an HD source and the other an SD source. I posted before I read the specs on his project (a noob mistake) and incorrectly assumed the two were comparable. Yes, he was defensive, but rightly so.
edit: I see you were referring to the Harmy edition being a fan edit, and I agree that name has a definite negative connotation.