logo Sign In

Post #539091

Author
doubleofive
Parent topic
Complete Comparison of Special Edition Visual Changes
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/539091/action/topic#539091
Date created
21-Sep-2011, 2:26 PM

zombie84 said:


So, I did an experiment last night with ANHSE by making a spreadsheet cataloging the changes. I used 005's changes album as the reference, but there were shots in the saber duel that he didn't include (an other shots had multiple pics for a single shot) so I had to go through that shot by shot myself to get each cut; there were a lot. I suspect this may also be the case with the trench run regarding some of the cockpit BG replacements, as the changes album only includes the one shot of Luke. So, my spreadsheet might need to have more added. The 2011 changes aren't included, but I did note when the 2004 version introduced something or modified something, but I didn't include the 1981 crawl as a change.
NICE! This is great, I love solid fact numbers. Sorry about the duel, I wanted to get all of the saber shots AND all of the flashes where you couldn't see the sabers very well, so there was a lot of doubling. You said I missed some though? And the cockpit backgrounds?

I noticed that several of the "we had to go through all of the trench footage to find the ones to recomposite suchandsuch shot" shots have never been pointed out as being changed from our nearly frame-by-frame analysis. We notice the ones where they reposition the ships ever so slightly, but what about the ones they actually did perfectly?