Not even close. Everything was so out of proportion and fake looking. When the camera was in the stands looking at the players, they looked horribly hokey. When the camera was in the sky showing the stands, you could see it was blatant CGI. No attempt was made to make it look realistic because they wanted to get the movie out on time. The Quidditch matches are one of the major reasons I dislike the first two movies so much. At least, compared to the third one.

I thought you were a proponent of good CGI, Jimbo. These are two examples of CGI at their worst. Okay, maybe not as bad as Deep Blue Sea, but still and all the same.