I had this thought about the BDs the other day.
If there are 2 Star Wars camps- this release should satisfy neither of them.
Camp 1 AKA "Us" - Either want just the originals, or tasteful, restrained updates to some of the effects (matte work, whatever). This BD release is obviously not that.
Camp 2 AKA "Ugh..."- Want the be all/end all version. With the best colours and sound that modern technology can supply and all of the latests "visions" that George Lucas has been having. The BD isn't that either.
So why are people still buying this?