logo Sign In

Post #533219

Author
zombie84
Parent topic
What HASN'T been changed to reflect GL's "original intent"
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/533219/action/topic#533219
Date created
7-Sep-2011, 5:23 PM

American Hominid said:

Something that I believe is driving many changes is the evolution of the prequel storyline. 

It vaguely focused on Ben's story when the the OT was made, but as the PT was developed, Anakin became more and more the main character til eventually the six-film saga became "The Tragedy of Darth Vader."  The addition of Hayden and the "NOOO"s to Jedi are, I think, efforts to emphasize Anakin's place as the (now) main character.  A more fatherly Anakin ghost makes sense for Luke's journey, but now it's all about Anakin.  Adding a line that reminds us of ROTS obviously makes us conflate ROTS Anakin with ROTJ Vader. 

There are remnants of the original thoughts in the films.  "When I left you, I was but a learner," Ben calling Vader "Darth," Vader not being a real viewpoint character in ANH... etc.

This is a good thing to keep in mind.

It's why we have stuff like Hayden ghost, Ian McDiarmid emperor, NOOooo, and even things like Naboo in ROTJ, Temura Morrison as Fett, and a lot of the expanded vistas/CG in the films are done in order to tie them to the PT better. A lot of the new shots were even done for the sole purpose of training for the PT. So, had there been no PT, the Special Editions would be comparably tamer and probably decently tasteful--although you'd probably still have Greedo shooting first.