timdiggerm said:

Point taken, particularly about the movement. I don't mind a little PT in my OT if we're trying to tie them together as a saga (as both Ady and Lucas are doing, really), but point taken.

Nor I.....but I DO firmly believe that Lucas is working backwards. Instead of making the PT feel more like what he had already created, he made it completely different and is going back to attempt to make the originals fit better with his new "films". The dug IMHO is the least invasive of all the changes....BUT it was done wrong. It should have been re-clothed, so as not to be a blatant copy of the AOTC one.....then should have been made to fit the action of that particular shot (some half-way decent CGI would go a long way as well)