dark_jedi said:

Sevb32 said:

Reviews should not be allowed until the set is released. Amazon.com needs to overhaul their review system. They've needed to for years.

I couldn't agree with you more, even though some of these changes suck really bad, reviews should NOT be allowed until they are officially released, because you have all these people posting comments that do not even have the Set LOL.

WOW, I am agreeing with Frink again.

I disagree that reviews should not be allowed until they are officially released. Some people get their hands on the products before they are officially released, and they should have the opportunity to review the product right then. Also, in the case of movies, people who have already seen the movie should be allowed to review the movie's plot, etc. If one thinks that a movie is horrible, one shouldn't have to wait to relive the garbage on DVD/BD in order to review it.

The changes for the SW BD's have been confirmed and that is enough for a lot of people to decide not to buy. I like the fact that the set has only a 2 star rating before its official release, as some people (who haven't done their research) will wonder why it has a low rating, drill into the reviews, and find out that they too will not support George Lucas by either not ordering or cancelling their pre-order.

I do think that DVD and Bluray releases of the same movie should have separate reviews/ratings, but that's a different story.