Uncanny Antman said:

miker71 said:

FWIW, it doesn't sound like JEJ to me either. Maybe one day I'll do a frequency spectrum comparison, but maybe not.

I've never believed it either. And for the record, I doubt that some of Vader's dialogue from Ep III is JEJ too. "Where is Padme? Is she safe, is she alright?" sounds like him, but the following lines about "I? I couldn't have, she was alive!" sound very un-JEJ to me. They seem 'thin' and processed just like the "Prepare for my arrival" from ESB.

The June 2005 issue of Starlog magazine talks about how JEJ worked at least one day recording dialogue for ROTS.

Also, someone brought up amazon.com reviews. I have thought for years that their review system is a joke, I think it's ridiculous that they allow reviews of things that are not even out yet, and they lump all releases in the same review as a previous release(s) of the same movies. Reviews should be a well-rounded reviews of the entire set, not just half or less.