Harmy said:

.....there is no reason to change it. Especially if you're basically just recreating with CGI what's originally been done perfectly with practical FX.

Oh, and in the last sample, you can see pieces of the original DS on the edges of the CG one.

You're absolutely right Harmy, I quickly pasted the new render over the image....there is even a matte blocking off some of the stars.....I posted it just to show different lighting and contrast as suggested by another post

......also the reason for going CG is not to recreate what has been done before, I did this 'sketch' to showcase Angels (very well done) Death Star model, by trying to emulate the compositions from the original movie,.....in the end I would be happy with a more dynamic new composition.

Thanks for feedback guys