xhonzi said:

There are a few positive aspects of the PT that I can think of (and there are whole threads dedicated to that) but I would agree with TPR that Liam Neeson isn't one of them. You said it that it's hard to find fault with Neeson and I don't find it hard at all. There does seem to be a fair amount of Qui-Gon love on these boards, but I can safely say I don't understand it in the least.

And this is coming from a chap who, while not having any posters or tattoos of the man, consider him to generally be a highlight of the pictures he's in. I can't say I go out of my way to see all of his movies, but I generally consider him to be a plus.

Just not in TPM. For the same reasons as TPR already listed. I find him terribly dull and flat. And wholly unconvincing.

EDIT: Something positive about MJPollard's post... Well, it was bold. Or do I just have to be positive about TPR's post? It was true. Wait, I guess I replied to MJP afterall... It was... defeated?

EXCOMMUNICATION!!!!!!