Right now, I'm having mixed feeling about the "Nooooo". On one hand it does add a feeling for Darth, who can no longer have the Emperor control him like a puppet, knowing his love for his son is more powerful. On the other hand, it is an insult to us fans who hoped the original scene would be left alone. The original will never be topped by another. I'm fine with the 2004 editions, but I hope thses changes to the Blu-Ray are the last time. Plus, one can hope this incident will convince George to full restore the original theatrical versions of the saga for Blu-Ray with NO changes. Incidentally, if and when I get a Blu-Ray player, I'm buying this set becuase to me, it's would an honor to have Star Wars in my collection. This has been My 2 Cents.