Count me in as one that just doesn't see the point of the "NOOOO". That scene worked perfectly as is, with Vader making a decision while hearing his son's pleas. Now, it's like he's vocally trying to convince himself this is wrong to act.

Though I must say that as awful as this is, so far the changes have been much more subtile than I expected. Maybe I just don't know about the others, as I'm still digging through the thread. Some minor effects work, pointless and bad looking touches to R2 and Wicket, and some horrid sound changes. Honestly, I expected more. The new CGI is atrocious, but that's no shocker either. The SE was always half-assed and well below ILM's level. It always did irritate me even more because of such. Why should that change?

Still can't see myself buying this set, as much as I want the extras. I also agree that it's odd Lucas has no problem releasing unfinished deleted scenes, but can't release the theatrical cuts in decent quality.