TV's Frink said:

And adywan is making fanedits, not official releases.

Yet (some) people liked the changes Ady made, except when is George making them, they criticize it no matter what.

I don't think it's fair to compare changes he makes and changes Lucas makes...

I think it's fair to compare the reaction of people to the same kind of changes. What I think it's not fair is Lucas giving us a sub-par special edition. ;-)

I don't think the argument of "preservation of the movies with zero changes" is valid on this thread, since everyone knew from the start we were not getting them on this set. It's just a mute point.