Uncanny Antman said:

Puggo - Jar Jar's Yoda said:

Uncanny Antman said:

Wait, now we're angry that they are making more changes? Boy, I can't keep up with what is an acceptable change and what isn't.

Oh, c'mon... that's the old "nobody will ever be satisfied" straw man. It's really quite easy: in the absence of a decent release of the theatrical version, the only acceptable changes would be those that UNDO the changes that have been made between 1983 and 2006.

My only point was that people seemed quick to jump on the new Wicket eyes, but when Ady does it (or Yoda gets replaced wholesale) it's mostly embraced.

Well, the Yoda thing has been known for at least a year (or more?), so people have had time to process it. Not to mention the TPM puppet was terrible.

And adywan is making fanedits, not official releases. I don't think it's fair to compare changes he makes and changes Lucas makes...especially on a site dedicated to the preservation of the movies with zero changes.