well danny_boy is spouting his shit again, but he isn't goading me into getting suspended. Funny how he hasn't got the bottle to come back in here, where we can actually have a discussion about these problems without being suspended or banned, to post the same crap he's been posting over there with his camera shot/ vcd proof. But that's because people here don't just blindly follow all the crap excuses for all the errors and here they know the errors with the 2004 transfers and can prove him wrong. Bloody pink lightsabres...

originally posted by fanny_boy:

LOL!

I guess it's just a coincidence that only the scenes in that techniclor print that contain vader's saber are the one's where the white balance of the camera that took these fotos was thrown out(convenient huh?)

Seriously ---when are you going to understand/concede that the original versions never had any consistency(which is something to be acknowledged and quite frankly celebrated).

And your very subjective bias that the 2004 DVD(and the hidef master from which it is derived) is an inferior product is laughable.
In terms of clarity,dynamic range and resolution,it is light years ahead of any previous laserdisc/VHS transfer.

That is why you used it as the basis for your own fan edit?

Just thought I would highlight that contradiction.

For the record I really like your edits.
But that is all they are and ever will be-- an exceptionally well executed fan edit---nothing more or less.

I hope you understand that.

How come these mindless followers feel the need to bring my edits into the argument, when they have nothing to do with the subject? And the other thing they bring up is clarity and resolution. You can present a turd in HD but it will still be a turd. Don't these people even care about quality any more?

They do seem to be like a little cult (or something that sounds quite similar. lol). The way they all gang up on anyone who has their own opinions about the movies.