OK well I think I have figured it out. I had downloaded the PAL DVD-9, and I guess my Blu Ray player doesn't support PAL DVD's, just NTSC DVD's. Which is weird, considering that every other DVD player in my North American home will play the PAL version of ANH:R. Well anyways I am downloading the NTSC version now, hopefully this works.
If it does, thank you for making a NTSC version, Ady!
LOL