Bingowings said:
Yes but you replied to his rating based on criteria of your own choosing.
If you were using that system to explain and illustrate your own rating it would make sense but using it to critique a blanket rating post made by somebody else doesn't make much sense contextually.
Oh, I certainly use those criteria in my ratings, but that doesn't mean I can't suggest that someone else's rating is due to not considering these criteria.
Ultimately, you can take any criteria and use them to rate a movie in whatever way - but a lot of criteria and aspects can be missed, and later used to reconsider one's own opinions ;)