captainsolo said:

Despite all of the correct criticisms of TPM and RLM's spot-on review, TPM still works as a movie. That's it. It's not particularly great or bad just a really good dose of meh.

Well, I would say about the same about ROTS. Maybe even more so.

At any rate, my question was rather how someone could rate it equally to ROTJ - because I think saying that VI was kinda a "meh disappointing finale to the trilogy" and "TPM was still meh, not horrible" is losing grip of proportions.

But thanks anyway, just something I wanted off my mind ;)

As for me, I'm struggling to give those movies an exact rating, so I think I'll pass.