I think that was about ESB though. And with ANH, Ady never claimed it to be 97SE reconstruction and these colours (in terms of palette, not vibrancy) are pretty close to the GOUT.
So DJ, do you mean using LD footage only, or do you mean using the DTV captures and using the LD footage where the smearing is really bad? Because I think in most places the DTV captures are superior, especially ANH (the DTV captures of ESB and ROTJ 97SE are pretty crap).