twooffour said:

Alright then, seems like you're on brickwall mode today... is there ANY way to get through to you? Please?
It's so, so simple...

His idea... doesn't change anything. Do you get that?
He thinks he's improving a major plot hole (that everyone should know about Anakin-Vader and be wary of Luke), but he's thought up this plot hole, and makes the story into WHAT IT ALREADY IS.

Okay, I'll break this down for you for the last time, real simple:

{snipped due to boredom}

Please... this has nothing to do with my "taste"; his solution is nonsensical, it doesn't solve anything he claims to be solving, and is based on getting the FACTS from the movies wrong.

{even more boring, also snipped}

Bingo, why even try?