Bingowings said:

DarthJarJar said:

twooffour said:

LOL

So your convoluted scheme achieves what exactly?
Instead of Anakin being the fallen Jedi who becomes Darth Vader... he's the fallen Jedi who defeated Darth Vader and assumed his name? What?

Convoluted eh? Not like the plot of Eps 1, 2 and 3 which are incredibly complex and make NO SENSE at all (copyright redlettermedia :)). I thought this was a forum for how we would have done ROTJ differently so this was MY opinion. Admittedly it diverged a bit off topic with the turn of Anakin but that is important for ROTJ.

Don't listen to him it's an interesting re-jig.

And it ties in with the long form of the Biggs deleted scene where Red Leader remembers Luke's father (not to mention many a Marvel comic pre-1980).

Where? Which? It's in none of the "well-known" ones (the bar, the farewell, at the rebel base), so it must be OBSCURE.

At any rate, it's a DELETED scene. It's deleted. It doesn't have to be explained away by any "rewrites" - just keep the scene out of the movie!

And anyways, Biggs didn't say anything about Luke's father becoming Darth Vader, right? I mean, they hadn't even thought that up during ANH (where Biggs died, you know), so he probably just... mentioned Skywalker Senior and what an awesome guy he was?

Because according to DarthJarJar, everyone in the rebellion knew about Anakin/Darth Vader, but didn't tell Luke (based on the fact that he was surprised to learn about it).
But hey, don't listen to me... don't listen to reason, or apply scrutiny... it's an interesting "re-jig", bro!