logo Sign In

Post #518194

Author
Harmy
Parent topic
Harmy's RETURN OF THE JEDI Despecialized Edition HD - V3.1
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/518194/action/topic#518194
Date created
30-Jul-2011, 3:56 PM

Erikstormtrooper said:

Here's the second and final part of my review:

Thanks a lot :-)


1:41:26 - some kind of encoding/compression glitch on the bottom of the AT-ST as it blows up. Is this the secret glitch?

 

I don't see anything there, could you maybe post a screenshot? (And no, it's not the secret glitch ;-)  )


1:56:25 - Wedge looks like his contrast has been jacked way up - muddled blacks, blown out whites, and excessive grain. The other shots in the reactor core look like they suffer from this slightly.

I'm afraid that is inherent to the 04 transfer.

2:01:09 - GOUT cuts to shot of ghosts, but DeEd stays on Luke and Leia and repeats a few frames. DeEd then cuts to ghosts about a half second late, then cuts to the final hero shot a half second late. This is probably to work around the trimmed shots in the SE, but the repeated frames of Luke and Leia at 2:01:09 should probably be removed in some way. Can you slow down the ghost shot?

That's just a mistake, I forgot to cut off the end of the despecialized shot when inserting it, it will of course not appear this way :-)

2:01:22 - the credits for the GOUT change about half a second before the DeEd. This runs to the end of the credits. Judder on credits is also quite noticable. Is this from DJ's Project Blu?

 

Yeah, the workprint credits are straight GOUT and are just temporary until DJ sends me those from his project. Those first few seconds of the credits are from DJ's project Blu and the difference just goes to show how much worse this project would be if I didn't have access to DJ's footage. He's so patient with me asking for more and more clips, I'm very grateful :-)