i agree with op im tired of people cutting the yoda vs emperor duel. i do like obiwan vs anakin as one straight sequence though.
My Youtube Accounts OfficialPeterFisher http://www.youtube.com/user/OfficialPeterFisher and JediMasterFisher http://www.youtube.com/user/JediMasterFisher
JediMasterFisher said:
i agree with op im tired of people cutting the yoda vs emperor duel.
I would like to see someone turn it into a dream/meditation sequence like the cave in ESB.
It's the only way to account for the bizarre OTT nature of the sequence.
The senate chairs could be filled with corpses and it could all be in slow motion with distorted sound and end with Qui-Gon's voice contacting Yoda.
LOL, I first read "the bizarre OT nature of the sequence"!
We are in acronym central :-D
The best edit of Episode III is definitly mine.
But I guess I will never release it...
Release or it didn't happen.Master Qui-Gon said:
The best edit of Episode III is definitly mine.
But I guess I will never release it...
TV's Frink said:
Release or it didn't happen.Master Qui-Gon said:
The best edit of Episode III is definitly mine.
But I guess I will never release it...
This.
So far, I've seen JasoN's version of Ep III and Stankpac's. Of the two, I'd have to say that I prefer Stankpac's right now. Though, that'll probably change once L8wrtr's Dawn of the Empire is released.
So as of right now, I'd recommend Stankpac's. It turned it into a better film, imo.
necro'd.
I've been looking around at several different fanedits over the years, and thus far it seems to me that Q2's Fall of the Jedi Trilogy is the best prequel trilogy. Primarily, his Episode III is the best Ep 3 edit I've seen so far.
At first, I greatly preferred Stankpac's edit, though his DVD release had no menu and his title card had a nearly-naked woman on it. When he released later versions, however, the DVD menus looked amateurish and his Palpatine "Sith-reveal" was done poorly.
I've watched Kerr's Dark Force Rising, and it is good as far as content, but the whole thing is sped up. As in, the framerate of the movie is increased. Not only is the video faster than it feels it should be, but also the voices of the characters are higher pitched and it's jarring.
While L8wrtr's Episode 1 and 2 are good, his Episode 3 includes Chewbacca and removes Yoda's use of a lightsaber without showing how he managed to escape from the clones. Also, as mentioned previously, his "sith-reveal" wasn't done well because it's not obvious why Palpatine looks different.
chyron just put a big Ric pic in your sig and be done with it.