logo Sign In

Post #514170

Author
twooffour
Parent topic
When Remakes are a Bad Idea
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/514170/action/topic#514170
Date created
15-Jul-2011, 4:40 PM

TV's Frink said:

twooffour said:

RedFive said:

So where does "logic" fit into the left half?

If I say that, in a music-film analogy, re-editing would be equivalent to remixing, and re-recording would be equivalent to remaking, would that be an opinion? Or fact? Would it be a logical fact? Or an opinion backed up by logic?

What about the other way round, remixing a recording is like reshooting a movie, while playing after a transcription of an audio recording, is like fan editing a movie?
Would that be also just an opinion? That can't be wrong? Would it be "disputable"?

It doesn't matter -- you dismiss everything you disagree with because you think your opinions all belong to the left half.

Well I'm still not sure where "reasonably backed up opinions" fit in, so there's only so much I can take from that one.