RedFive said:

So where does "logic" fit into the left half?

If I say that, in a music-film analogy, re-editing would be equivalent to remixing, and re-recording would be equivalent to remaking, would that be an opinion? Or fact? Would it be a logical fact? Or an opinion backed up by logic?

What about the other way round, remixing a recording is like reshooting a movie, while playing after a transcription of an audio recording, is like fan editing a movie?
Would that be also just an opinion? That can't be wrong? Would it be "disputable"?